Skip to content
Banilya ShopA shopper's guide to real vanilla

Guide two

Extract & Labels

The vanilla aisle is full of similar-looking bottles at very different prices. Knowing what the words on the label mean is the quickest way to get what you are paying for.

Two swing-top bottles of amber homemade vanilla extract with beans inside, next to a small measuring jug
Homemade extract needs only beans, spirit and patience.

Common label terms

On the label What it usually means
Pure vanilla extract Vanilla beans extracted in alcohol and water. In the United States, the name is reserved for extract made to a federal standard with at least 35 percent alcohol and a set minimum of beans per gallon.
Vanilla flavouring Often vanilla extract with less alcohol, or a blend with other flavourings
Natural flavour Flavour from a natural source, not necessarily vanilla beans
Imitation vanilla Usually synthetic vanillin, without the other compounds in real beans
Vanilla bean paste Extract thickened with sugar or gum, with real seeds suspended in it
Double-fold Extract made with twice the usual amount of beans, so it is stronger

Labelling rules differ between countries, including between the UK, the EU and the US. When in doubt, read the full ingredients list.

Vanillin versus vanilla

Vanillin is the best-known flavour compound in vanilla, but real beans contain hundreds of others that add depth. Vanillin can also be made from other sources, which is why imitation vanilla is so much cheaper. In heavily spiced or long-baked recipes, many people find the difference hard to taste; in custards, ice cream and simple cakes it is easier to notice.

Making your own extract

  1. Split several beans lengthways. Grade B beans are ideal.
  2. Put them in a clean glass bottle and cover them completely with a neutral spirit of about 40 percent alcohol, such as vodka.
  3. Seal and store somewhere cool and dark, shaking now and then.
  4. Wait at least two months, and longer for a deeper flavour.
  5. Top up with more spirit as you use it, adding a fresh bean now and then.

Homemade extract is for your own kitchen. Selling food or drink made with alcohol is regulated, so check local rules before giving or selling it beyond friends and family.

Storing extract

Keep extract tightly closed in a cool, dark cupboard. Pure extract keeps for years thanks to its alcohol content.

Next guide: Baking with Vanilla